An E85 engine is a gasoline engine with some parts changed to be non-corrosive to ethanol. Since ethanol contains less energy per gallon, burning it in a low compression ratio gasoline engine results in very poor mileage -- 75% of that of gasoline.
If you go 300 miles on a tank of gasoline, and fill it with E85, you will only go 225 miles. For every 3 stops to fill-up with gasoline, the driver will have to stop 4 times if running E85.
In 2019, ~14.5 billion gallons of fuel grade ethanol was used in the US(EIA MER Table 10.3, 7/28/20). Of this, >99% is blended into E10 and only ~117 million gallons (AEO, 1/29/2020. Table 17) <1%, into E85.
The current process is that the ethanol producer ships the ethanol to the oil company blender who blends it with gasoline to make either E10 or E85.
This process means that the oil companies control the price of E85 just like they control the price of gasoline. E85 is priced so that it costs the consumer more money to burn E85 per mile than gasoline, roughly $400 per year according to www.fueleconomy.gov. The ethanol industry does not control the price of its product to the final consumer. This is a huge strategic error.
E85 began life due to a government mandate, the Corporate Average Fuel Economy Act (CAFE). It has been in the marketplace for 25 years, since 1992, with 100's of millions of dollars of advertising put into it. It has gained only 0.1% market share penetration (117 million gals over 143 billion gals of gasoline) after all that time and money. (AEO Jan 2020, Table 17.)
Consumers have plainly indicated they aren't buying this product. The vast majority of gasoline retailers are franchisees, not owned by the oil companies. They are very reluctant to purchase E85 and put it into one of their tanks since they believe it won't sell. They are right.
This is why, as of September 2020, there are only 5,015 E85 stations in the US (E85Prices.com), not because of any distribution problems or lack of E85 capable vehicles.
Another way to look at this is: If E85 offered the same mileage as gasoline, we would have switched over to it long ago since it costs less per gallon, and motor fuel is a very price sensitive product.
E15, E20, E30
There is a lot of consideration being given to intermediate blends such as E15, E20, and E30 and the EPA has approved the sale of E15 for certain model year vehicles and a few stations in the U.S. are selling it.
There is a good case for E15 in that it would immediately help the ethanol industry which is having trouble growing due to the informal blend limit of 10% ethanol.
However, there is a real dispute about potential problems with storage tanks, piping, and pumps. Also, there is no requirement that E15 actually be used and even if it comes into use, it cannot make us independent of imported oil or significantly lower CO2 emissions.
Beyond that level, trying to go to E20 or E30, there are problems:
1. the oil companies will still control the price of the fuel,
2. it is a lot of work to do it,
3. the same amount of money will have to be spent to convert dispensers and tanks to the higher levels of ethanol as we would spend to convert to E100, and,
4. last, but not least, if a terrorist group send a bomb or plane into Abqaiq or Ras Tanura, we have skyrocketing fuel prices again with all the attendant problems.
Copyright © 2020 E100 Ethanol Group - All Rights Reserved.
Last Updated October 5, 2020